Tasting the Legend: The Remarkable 1973 Stag's Leap Cabernet Sauvignon

On July 15, 2026, a rare bottle of 1973 Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars S.L.V. Cabernet Sauvignon fetched an astonishing $22,500 at a Christie’s auction—nearly quadrupling its high estimate of $6,000. Just weeks prior, I had the unique privilege of tasting another bottle from this historic vineyard's dwindling collection.

To appreciate the significance of such a wine, one must experience it firsthand, and that's a privilege few get to enjoy.

The History Behind the Wine

During an exclusive tasting at Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars, hosted by owner Marchese Piero Antinori and winemaker Marcus Notaro, I sampled the celebrated 1973 Cabernet alongside notable wine journalists. This particular vintage is part of the Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History collection, recognized as one of the ‘101 Objects that Made America.

At the time of tasting, only 19 bottles of this vintage were said to remain in the winery's reserve, adding to the excitement.

The Judgment of Paris

The wine earned historical acclaim on May 24, 1976, when it triumphed over French competitors in a pivotal blind tasting held in Paris orchestrated by Steven Spurrier and Patricia Gallagher. This tasting featured California and Bordeaux wines, with the S.L.V. emerging victorious among ten contenders in a predominantly French judging panel.

Notaro meticulously opened the vintage with care, ensuring the cork's integrity remained intact. The decanting process proved to be equally delicate, met with relief as the wine flowed, showcasing its deep ruby hue with only slight signs of aging—a testament to its impeccable condition.

As part of the experience, I got to hold an original Time magazine from 1976, featuring George Taber’s article on the tasting. Interestingly, the piece mistakenly identified the winning vintage as the 1972 instead of 1973. But errors like that are just footnotes in the grand narrative of wine history.

The Tasting Experience

While savoring the '73 Cabernet, each taster described their impressions. Renzo Cotarella, the Antinori CEO, noted the wine originated from the vineyard's third crop of grapes, typically yielding extraordinary flavors.

Rich aromas of tobacco, charcuterie, and black truffle danced in the glass, complemented by loamy earth, currant fruit, and white pepper notes. It was the wine's liveliness that resonated most strongly—a bright acidity that invigorated the palate rather than diminishing during the meal.

Paired with an exquisite meal featuring shaved fennel, Hokkaido sea scallops, and hanger steak, the 1973 Cabernet continually evolved, enhancing its appeal rather than waning. The accompanying bottles, including the softer, more rounded 1987 S.L.V. and the minty 1999 vintage, further illustrated the theme of Napa Cabernet's resilient longevity.

Antinori's acquisition of Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars—initially a 15% stake in 2007, culminating in full ownership by 2023—has ushered in a new era for the vineyard. The inaugural 2023 vintage released under Antinori’s full ownership garnered praise for its 'Margaux-like' notes, affirming Napa’s potential.

The Importance of Cellaring

In reflecting on the tasting, I encourage fellow wine lovers to invest in bottles that resonate deeply with them. Store them carefully for future enjoyment, and consider sharing these treasures with future generations.

Specific vintages from Napa, notably from 2013 and 2021, showcase profound structure and concentration, while the 2016 and 2019 present complex bold flavors. As for the '73 S.L.V., it remains an extraordinary choice—if I had to select one final wine, it would undoubtedly be this vintage.

That says it all. This wine is nothing short of exceptional.

Related Articles